The Sugarcookies, slushees
Known for its gooey, just-baked chocolate chip cookies packed with rich chocolate, but the sleeper hit might be the corn cookie—a craveable cross between sugar cookie and cornbread. Baked in small batches daily across all three NYC locations.
Latinsky.c
10/31/2025
gooey
megmatthis
10/28/2025

brookdarby
10/6/2025
best chocolate chip and oatmeal/cranberry cookies

christopherholmes
10/5/2025

ErinsEatsNY
9/30/2025
See more taster notes in the app!