The SugarThe Sugarcupcakes, cakes, cookies, cheesecake, ice cream, pies, pudding
Brooklyn-born and family-run since 2005, this shop whips up nostalgic classics—from Brooklyn Blackout to Good Humor Strawberry Shortcake—in cupcakes, layer cakes, and cookies, all baked fresh in small batches with local ingredients.
Carliesfooddiary
10/30/2025
the banana Nutella cake. blackout cake. everything is absolutely perfect my favorite bakery in NYC and perhaps ever. we did damage
monster
10/7/2025
nataliey
10/1/2025
ErinsEatsNY
9/30/2025
valerie
9/30/2025
See more taster notes in the app!
