Name: The Pastry Box
Address: 515 E 12th St, New York, NY
Telephone: +16464298717
Rating: 4.5

the scoop

Chef-owner Tiara Bennett’s East Village bakery is a cookie lover’s dream—famous for gooey chocolate chip cookies (including a half-pound beast), buttery brownies, and NYC-classic black-and-whites.

Taster Notes

sophiablake

10/13/2025

best buttery chocolate chip cookie, especially for thin cookie lovers! don’t miss the black and white cookie either!

monster

10/7/2025

brookdarby

10/6/2025

LikelyALlama

10/1/2025

valerie

9/30/2025

best desserts

See more taster notes in the app!